Guides

Legacy systems and Cyber Essentials: replace, isolate or descope

Cyber Essentials v3.3: remove unsupported software or move it to a sub-set with no internet traffic. A decision guide for old Windows, legacy apps and lab kit.

By Precursor SecurityIASME Certification Body
Published
Reviewed
Reading time
9 min

Reviewed against Requirements v3.3 and Danzell v16.3.

Short answer

Cyber Essentials v3.3 requires all in-scope software to be licensed and supported. Unsupported software must be removed or moved to a sub-set, separated by a firewall or VLAN, that prevents all traffic to or from the internet. Paying for extended security updates keeps a product supported. If the isolated sub-set still reaches the internet, only partial certification is possible.

Key takeaways

  1. NCSC Requirements v3.3 say all software on in-scope devices must be licensed and supported, and removed when it becomes unsupported or moved to a defined sub-set that prevents all traffic to or from the internet.
  2. A6.3 and A6.6 carry no automatic-fail wording in the Danzell question set, but IASME's FAQ says any company using unsupported software in scope will fail to achieve certification.
  3. A6.7 says that if an out-of-scope sub-set remains connected to the internet, you cannot achieve whole-company certification and must select Partial Organisation in A2.1.
  4. Extended security updates keep a product supported while you pay for them; the A6.1 guidance applies this to Windows 10 after 14 October 2025.
  5. The CE Plus test specification v3.2 says virtual patching will not be recognised as compliance for legacy unsupported operating systems.
Key facts
The rule
Sub-set
Questions
Extended support
Not accepted

Almost every organisation has one: the old server that runs the stock system, the PC attached to a lab instrument, the accounts package nobody has upgraded since 2015. Cyber Essentials does not have a hardship exemption for these. It does give you three ways to deal with them. This guide explains the rule, the questions it appears in, and how to decide between replacing, isolating and descoping. Scheme facts come from the NCSC Requirements for IT Infrastructure v3.3 and the IASME Danzell question set v16.3, checked on 9 November 2026.

What does Cyber Essentials say about unsupported software?

The scheme requires all software on in-scope devices to be licensed and supported, and unsupported software to be removed or moved out of scope.

The Requirements for IT Infrastructure v3.3 say all software on in-scope devices must:

  • "be licensed and supported"
  • "be removed from devices when it becomes unsupported, or removed from scope by using a defined sub-set that prevents all traffic to or from the internet"

v3.3 defines licensed and supported software as software you have a legal right to use "and that a vendor has committed to support by providing regular vulnerability fixes. The vendor must provide the future date when they will stop providing these." Software includes "operating systems, commercial off-the-shelf applications, extensions, interpreters, scripts, libraries, network software and firewall and router firmware". That list is why an old Java runtime or a forgotten browser plug-in counts as much as an old operating system.

Which questions ask about legacy systems?

Five questions in the security update management section cover it, plus A2.1 to A2.2.2 if you descope part of the network: A6.1 and A6.2 ask whether everything is supported, A6.3 and A6.6 ask about unsupported software, and A6.7 asks how you took it out of scope.

A6.3 and A6.6 are not automatic fails in the question set. That does not make them optional: the question set's introduction to security update management says that if an in-scope device uses an unsupported operating system without regular vulnerability fixes, "then you will not be awarded certification". A non-compliant answer means the licensed-and-supported requirement is not met, and the assessor will expect the software to be upgraded, removed or isolated before certification. Our post on the answers that fail automatically explains the difference.

How do you decide whether to replace, isolate or descope?

Replace or upgrade if you can, isolate with no internet traffic if the business needs the system, and descope only if isolation is not possible and a partial certificate is acceptable.

The A6.7 guidance is explicit: "If the out-of-scope sub-set remains connected to the internet, you will not be able to achieve whole company certification and you must select 'Partial Organisation' in question A2.1." v3.3 also says you "will need to justify the reason for a partial scope to your assessor", and that whole-organisation scope gives "the best protection" and maximises customer confidence.

What counts as a sub-set with no internet traffic?

A sub-set is a part of your network segregated from the rest by a firewall or VLAN, and for unsupported software it must block all traffic to and from the internet.

That is the v3.3 definition, and the A6.7 guidance repeats it. A separate VLAN with a rule that still allows the old server to fetch updates or reach a supplier's portal does not qualify, because traffic still flows to the internet. In our reading, remote access by a supplier into the sub-set is also internet traffic. A2.2.2 adds that sub-sets must be built with a firewall or VLAN; security groups, microsegmentation and software-based methods "are not compliant".

Our interpretation: what a good A6.7 answer covers

An example A6.7 answer, with invented names, that covers each point:

Stock control server SRV-STOCK01 runs Windows Server 2012 R2, which is out of vendor support. We keep it because the stock application has no supported version; its replacement goes live in March 2027. The server sits alone on VLAN 30, created on our boundary firewall listed in A2.5. Firewall rules deny all traffic between VLAN 30 and the internet in both directions, and between VLAN 30 and every other VLAN. There is no supplier remote access. Two staff use it from a dedicated terminal on VLAN 30.

For Cyber Essentials Plus, the test specification v3.2 says the assessor must verify "by technical means" that sub-sets outside a partial scope "have been segregated effectively". It also states that "virtual patching is not an acceptable mitigation to the security vulnerabilities of legacy unsupported operating systems long term". A firewall rule or intrusion prevention signature in front of an old server does not make the server compliant.

How do common legacy systems work out?

Most cases resolve to upgrade, extended support, or isolation; here are the ones we see most often.

Windows 10. Keep it only while it is enrolled in Microsoft's Extended Security Updates programme, as the A6.1 guidance requires after 14 October 2025; Windows 10 and Cyber Essentials covers ESU eligibility and costs.

Windows 11 on unsupported hardware. Microsoft says that if you install Windows 11 on a PC that does not meet the minimum requirements, "your PC will no longer be supported and won't be entitled to receive updates" (Microsoft Support). In our reading that fails the v3.3 licensed-and-supported test, so treat these PCs like any other unsupported device: replace them or isolate them.

Old line-of-business applications. If the vendor no longer issues security fixes or will not give an end date, the application is unsupported. Ask the vendor for a supported version or a published support date first. If neither exists, move the application and its server into an isolated sub-set, or plan a replacement.

Lab, manufacturing and medical kit. Instruments often run an operating system the manufacturer will not let you upgrade. These are good candidates for an isolated sub-set, because they rarely need the internet. Results can move out on a controlled path that does not open internet access to the sub-set.

Old routers and firewalls. Firmware counts as an operating system under A6.1. In our reading, an ISP router or firewall that no longer receives firmware updates has no isolation option, because it controls internet traffic by definition. Replace it.

Common failure

Does open-source or third-party-supported software count?

It can, if someone is committed to issuing security fixes and publishes an end date.

A6.3 says "It is acceptable to use free and open-source software as long as you comply with any licensing requirements." The v3.3 definition notes that "the vendor doesn't need to have created the software originally, but they must be able to modify the original software to create fixes." In our reading, a distribution vendor that backports security fixes to an older package can meet that test, while a community project that has stopped releasing fixes cannot.

Recommended, not required

What should you do next?

List everything, check support dates, and choose one of the options for each unsupported item before you submit.

Start with the device and software lists the assessment asks for, then check each entry. Our scope guide explains which devices count, and the security update management requirements cover the 14-day rule that applies once everything is supported. Then check your readiness against the full question set. If you want an assessor to review a sub-set design before you rely on it, Precursor Security's gap analysis starts from £500, and Cyber Essentials from £1,500 with the IASME fee included.

Frequently asked questions

Then A6.4 or A6.5 is a no, and both are automatic fails. The question set says you must install high and critical updates 'within 14 days in all circumstances'. v3.3 counts vendor-approved fixes such as configuration changes or scripts as vulnerability fixes, so a vendor's documented workaround applied within 14 days can meet the rule. If neither is possible, the system has to be removed or moved to a sub-set with no internet traffic.

Not safely for Cyber Essentials. Microsoft says that if you install Windows 11 on such a PC, 'your PC will no longer be supported and won't be entitled to receive updates', and that these devices 'aren't guaranteed to receive updates, including but not limited to security updates'. In our reading that fails the v3.3 licensed-and-supported test, so replace the device or keep it in an isolated sub-set.

Yes. A standalone machine that cannot make or accept internet connections falls outside the v3.3 scope conditions, so it is out of scope without a sub-set. A networked machine running unsupported software must sit in a sub-set, separated from the rest of your network by a firewall or VLAN, that prevents all traffic to or from the internet; describe it in A6.7.

Then it cannot be out of scope while your certificate covers the whole organisation. The A6.7 guidance says that if the out-of-scope sub-set remains connected to the internet, you will not be able to achieve whole company certification and must select Partial Organisation in A2.1. The certificate then reads 'Partial Organisation', so confirm that your customer accepts a partial scope before you choose this route.

No. The CE Plus test specification v3.2 says virtual patching is not an acceptable long-term mitigation for legacy unsupported operating systems and will not be recognised as compliance with Cyber Essentials requirements. The software itself must be supported, removed, or in a sub-set with no internet traffic.

It can. A6.3 says free and open-source software is acceptable if you meet its licensing terms. v3.3 defines supported software as having a vendor committed to regular vulnerability fixes, with a published future date when fixes stop. The vendor need not have written the software, but must be able to modify it to create fixes.

Free readiness check

Would you pass the 2026 question set?

Answer 24 yes or no questions, built by Precursor Security, an IASME Cyber Essentials Certification Body, and get a readiness score in about five minutes, with any auto-fail questions you miss flagged first in your results.

  • IASME Certification Body
  • CREST accredited
  • UK offices in Leeds, Newcastle, London and Edinburgh
Newsletter

Scheme changes, once a month

Question-set updates, end-of-support dates and what our assessors are failing this month. No sales sequence. What each issue covers.

Your email is used only to send these updates. Unsubscribe in one click. Read the privacy policy.